Revolutionary Nuptials
William Godwin's Political Justice
"The abolition of marriage will be attended with no evils. We are apt
to represent it to ourselves as the harbinger of brutal lust and
depravity. But it really happens in this as in other cases, that the
positive laws which are made to restrain our vices, irritate and multiply
them. Not to say, that the same sentiments of justice and happiness which
in a state of equal property would destroy the relish for luxury, would
decrease our inordinate appetites of every kind, and lead us universally
to prefer the pleasures of intellect to the pleasures of sense"
(850-851).
In 1793, William Godwin published his Enquiry
Concerning Political Justice, a well-received work which gained
him high praises from "people of literary and intellectual distinction"
(Allen 57). This piece differs from the other texts treated here, as it
is more philosophical and theoretical than the novels and stories of the
other authors.
Chapter VI of Political Justice, "Of the Objection to this System
from the Inflexibility of its Restrictions," addresses marriage as an
issue of property. Godwin asserts, "marriage is an affair of property,
and the worst of all properties" (Godwin 850). Of the four authors
examined within this section, Godwin opposes matrimony the most
passionately. He acknowledges that the institution is unjust to women,
hence discussing it in terms of property, but also thinks marriage is
damaging to all people. Godwin, something of an anarchist, believed that,
"as a genuine state of society is incomparable with all laws and
restrictions, so it cannot have even this restriction, that no man shall
amass property" (856). His problem with marriage includes but also
transcends issues of gender equality.
Part of the problem for Godwin comes from cohabitation. Godwin believed
that "all attachments to individuals, except in proportion to their
merits, are plainly unjust. It is therefore desirable, that we should be
the friends of man rather than of particular men, and that we should
pursue the chain of our own reflexions, with no other interruption than
information or philanthropy requires" (848). He applies this idea to
relationships between men and women as well. Cohabitation with anyone
"checks the independent progress of mind; it is also inconsistent with
the imperfections and propensities of man." This idea is similar to those
of Rousseau,
although the two thinkers have grossly different opinions about the role
of women.
Godwin also doubted the ability of mankind to stay devoted to one person
for an entire lifetime. Instead, he assumed that "it will be impossible
for me to live in the world without finding one man of a worth superior
to that of any other whom I have an opportunity of observing. To this man
I shall feel a kindness in exact proportion to my apprehension of his
worth" (851). He goes on to say that the same will be true of women but
that this problem is easily overcome for "we may all enjoy her
conversation; and we shall all be wise enough to consider the sensual
intercourse as a very trivial object" (851).
Like Murray and Wollstonecraft, Godwin felt all relationships should be
based on companionship and friendship. He preferred humans "universally
to prefer the pleasures of intellect to the pleasures of sense" (851). He
considers these relationships, which would not necessarily result in
marriage, as stronger and more lasting ties than institutional marriages.
For Murray and Wollstonecraft, marriages based on companionship mean that
women would require better educations so they can converse with their
husbands on a more equal level and be better at educating their children.
That being said, Godwin and Wollstonecraft, both opposed to the
institution of marriage, did eventually marry each another for the
protection of their daughter, the future Mary Shelley. Mary Hays introduced Godwin and
Wollstonecraft early in the 1790s, and then the two become lovers in
1796. Although the two married, they based their marriage on the
principles they had advocated for many years. Even after the two were
married they maintained separate apartments, reflecting Godwin's ideas
about cohabitation. Wollstonecraft died after giving birth to Mary,
and Godwin later married Mary Jane Clairmont in 1801, three years after
Wollstonecraft's death.
Relevant Bibliography Entries
- St. Clair, William. The Godwins and
the Shelleys: The Biography of a Family. New York: Norton,
1989.
- Clemit, Pamela. The
Godwinian Novel: The Rational Fictions of Godwin, Brockden Brown, Mary
Shelley. Oxford: Clarendon, 1993.
- Philp, Mark. Godwin's
Political Justice. Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1986.
- Fisher, Carl. "The Crowd and the
Public in Godwin's Caleb Williams." In Women, Revolution,
and the Novels of the 1790s. Ed. Linda Lang-Peralta. East Lansing:
Michigan State UP, 1999. 47-67.
- Benedict, Barbara M. "Radcliffe, Godwin,
and Self-Possession in the 1790s." In Women, Revolution,
and the Novels of the 1790s. Ed. Linda Lang-Peralta. East Lansing:
Michigan State UP, 1999. 89-110.
William Godwin's Timeline
- 1756 William Godwin is born on March 3 in Wisbech, North
Cambridgeshire, the seventh of thirteen children.
- 1773 Godwin enrolls at Hoxton Academy, one of the most prominent and
best Dissenting academies in the country.
- 1784 Godwin publishes two novels, Damon and Delia and
Italian Letters. He becomes regular contributer to the English
Review and The New Annual Register.
- 1785 Godwin writes for the new Whig journal, the Political Herald
and Review.
- 1791 Godwin meets Mary Wollstonecraft. He signs contract with George
Robinson to write a lengthy work of political
philosophy, which eventually becomes Political Justice.
- 1793 Godwin publishes An Enquiry Concerning Political Justice
on February 14. He begins writing Caleb
Williams and publishes "Letters of Mucius" in the Morning
Chronicle.
- 1794 Godwin publishes Things As They Are; or, The
Adventures of Caleb Williams. His Cursory
Strictures contributes to the acquittal of radicals on trial for
speech crimes.
- 1796 Godwin meets Mary Wollstonecraft again; they become
friends, then lovers in August.
- 1798 Godwin publishes The Enquirer, Reflections on
Education, Manners and Literature. Wollstonecraft becomes pregnant
and the two marry on March 29. A daughter, Mary, is born on August 30,
but Wollstonecraft dies of post-delivery complications on September 10.
- 1798 Godwin publishes his Memoirs of Mary
Wollstonecraft and her Posthumous Works.
- 1799 Godwin publishes St. Leon: A Tale of the Sixteenth
Century.
- 1801 Godwin eets and marries Mary Jane Clairmont, who brings her
daughter Jane and son Charles into Godwin's home.
- 1803 Godwin publishes his Life of Chaucer. William Godwin, Jr.
is born.
- 1805 Godwin publishes Fleetwood: or, The New Man of Feeling.
He and his wife establish the Juvenile Library for children's literature.
- 1815 Godwin publishes The Lives of Edward and John Philips.
- 1817 Godwin publishes Mandeville, A Tale of the Seventeenth
Century in England.
- 1818 Mary Shelley publishes Frankenstein and dedicates it to
Godwin.
- 1820 Godwin publishes Of Population in response to Thomas
Malthus's Essay on the Principle of Population.
- 1824-1828 Godwin begins publishing his History of the Commonwealth
of England.
- 1830 Godwin publishes Cloudesley: A Novel.
- 1831 Godwin publishes Thoughts on Man.
- 1832 William Godwin, Jr. dies of cholera.
- 1834 Godwin publishes Lives of the Necromancers and William
Godwin, Jr.'s novel Transfusion with a memoir of his son.
- 1836 Godwin dies in London on April 7.
<-- Previous Page | Next Page -->
|